A home health administrator in Ohio told me about her cyber insurance experience in early 2025. Her agency had carried a $1 million cyber liability policy for three years. They experienced a ransomware attack, incurred $340,000 in forensic, legal, and notification costs, filed a claim — and received $0. The insurer denied the claim on the basis that the agency had misrepresented its security controls in the application. Specifically: the application had stated that MFA was enforced on all remote access. MFA was available but not enforced — staff who chose not to enrol could still log in without it. The attacker used a credential stolen through phishing and authenticated without MFA. The insurer argued that the control was not in place as represented.
I have seen this pattern many times. Agencies that purchased cyber insurance in good faith, that believed they had the controls their applications described, and that discovered in the worst possible moment that "available" and "enforced" are not the same thing to an insurance adjuster. The denial was not technically fraudulent on the agency's part — it was a good-faith misrepresentation of the implementation status of a control. But the outcome was the same: no coverage when coverage was needed most.
The Four Most Common Reasons Healthcare Cyber Insurance Claims Are Denied
Reason 1: MFA Was Available But Not Enforced
This is the single most common denial basis I encounter in healthcare cyber insurance claim disputes. Underwriting applications ask whether MFA is implemented. The honest answer for many home health agencies at the time of application is that MFA is available — it has been enabled in the system settings — but enforcement is inconsistent. Staff who complete enrollment have MFA; staff who skip enrollment bypass it with username and password alone. From the underwriter's perspective, this is not MFA enforcement — it is MFA availability, which is materially different and which was not what the application stated.
The correct documentation: a configuration report from your identity platform showing that MFA is enforced through conditional access policy for 100% of accounts with ePHI access, with no bypass exceptions. A report showing 94% MFA enrollment is a report showing 6% of accounts are unprotected. Confirm enforcement, not enrollment.

